A name for something I already do

I spent twenty minutes the other week trying to explain to my mum and dad why I am pleased about a radio broadcast tonight. It is happening in Glasgow, on a station they have never heard of, playing something that is not exactly music. I did not do a very good job of it. Somewhere around the phrase “sound art” I watched my dad do the polite nod he does when he has decided to stop asking questions.

I am one of the people who set up and now help run Harrogate Community Radio, so explaining what happens on the radio is meant to be my job. Tonight I am being broadcast on Radiophrenia, an art radio station that comes out of Glasgow’s Centre for Contemporary Arts. This same week, Harrogate Community Radio carried an episode of RADIA network, a weekly show passed between stations across Europe, made this time by a group in San Marino who call themselves the Research Centre for Radiophonic Studies. Two broadcasts, one word, landing in the same seven days. So I went looking, not for where the word came from, but for what people who take it seriously actually think it means.

I did not have a definition for any of it. It turns out almost nobody who actually makes radio art agrees on one either.

Echoes with/out Origin

This hour-long radio artwork unfolds from shortwave recordings, captured and split into stems before being dub-mixed with delay and reverb. Drawing on hauntological ideas — where past signals linger like ghosts on the airwaves — it listens for the spectral traces in transmission and memory. As analog crackle and distant carriers bleed into processed space, the piece invites us to tune not just frequencies but time itself. A meditation on absence and presence broadcast on Radiophrenia’s FM and online dial.

What the people who actually do this say

Victoria Fenner, a radio producer, keeps it simple. Radio art, in her view, is work made specifically for radio, built in a way that only makes sense once it goes out over the airwaves. Robert Adrian, a Canadian artist who spent decades in Vienna arguing about exactly this, drew a harder line. In his view, radio art is its own category, separate from sound art and separate from music, and putting a piece of sound art out on the radio does not automatically turn it into one. The work exists wherever someone happens to be listening, he argued, never in the studio it was made in, and no artist can control what a listener’s own room and radio do to the final sound.

Tetsuo Kogawa, a Japanese media theorist who has spent decades building tiny FM transmitters barely strong enough to reach the next street, takes it further still. He does not even like the phrase radio art. He prefers radioart, one word, because he thinks the point is not the art, or even the radio, but the sending itself. In a manifesto from 2016 he put it about as plainly as anyone has: forget broadcasting, forget art-radio as a genre, what matters is the sending, full stop. That is the position I keep finding myself agreeing with most.

Not everyone agrees, even inside that world. Gregory Whitehead, who has made radio work for the BBC and NPR for decades, was once asked whether radio art has to be live to count. He said that nothing is ever fully unrecorded, since even a live broadcast carries the habits and training of everything that came before it, and that the more interesting question is what happens in the space between a live moment and a dead one. He also drew his own line elsewhere: John Cage once made a piece that used a radio as one prop among several. Whitehead does not count that as radio art. Using radio is not the same as making it.

Transmission, not release

After a week of reading, here is where I have landed. Kogawa has it closest to right, for me. Radio art, or radiophonic art, whatever you want to call it, is sound art that belongs on air rather than on a release, and I do not think there is a good enough reason to do it the other way round, whatever that reason is. Something that works exactly as well as a download or a pressed record probably was not radio art to begin with. It was sound art that happened to go out on the radio once, which Robert Adrian would say is not the same at all.

Field recording is the odd one out in all this, for me. A recording of a walk can be released, put on a record, played as many times as anyone likes. But something changes when the same recording goes out live instead, heard once by whoever is tuned in, then gone. Whitehead is right that nothing is fully unrecorded, my own field recordings included. But there is still a difference between a file you can return to and a signal that passes through a room once and is never heard that way again. I think that difference is the whole of it.

What I will tell my mum and dad, if I get a better run at it next time, is that tonight’s broadcast happens once. There is no replay button, no download, no way to hear it again exactly as it was. It goes out, whoever is listening hears it wrapped up in their own kitchen or car or dog walk, and then it is gone. I used to think losing the ability to keep a copy of your own work was one of the saddest parts of this. I am starting to think it might be the entire point.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *